Working Drawings
Topic Index
Once you've created one or more suitable concept sketches, the next
step is to make working drawings. These are drawings that are
proportionally accurate but at a reduced scale, often 1/4 of full size.
They are used to refine design details and to determine specific
dimensions of the various components. They also form the basis for the
bill of materials and cutlists. Unlike sketching, working drawings are
not drawn freehand, but rather are created with drafting tools (pencils,
erasers!, triangles, T-square, compass, French curve, ...) or with a CAD
package.
Orthographic Projection (Three-view Drawing)
Perhaps the most common type of working drawing is an orthographic
projection that provides separate straight-on views of the front, side
(usually right) and top of the object. All three views or elevations go
on the same piece of paper with the top view directly above the front
view and the right side view directly to the right of the front view.
Sample orthographic drawing of a trestle
table (Created with TurboCAD).
Orthographic drawings aren't difficult - they just require a little
patience and attention to detail. In his book,
Measure Twice, Cut Once, Jim Tolpin provides a bare-bones overview
of mechanical drafting for woodworkers, including a discussion of
orthographic or three-view drawings. This book has some very practical
advice and I highly recommend it. Meanwhile, here are a few guidelines
for creating an orthographic drawing:
Choose an appropriate scale. For furniture, a scale of either 1/8 in.
= 1 in. or 1/4 in. = 1 in. works well. Use an architects scale to easily
convert actual dimensions to scale dimensions.
If using paper, choose a good quality vellum or drafting paper that
is easy to erase !! Tape the paper to your drafting table (a flat piece
of plywood will suffice), making sure it is aligned with your T-square.
Put a border around the drawing, 1/4 to 1/2 inch from the edges of the
paper.
Insert a legend box that includes the project's name, your name, the
date, the scale, units of measurement (if not shown on the drawing) and
perhaps information such as the wood types to be used. For commercial
work, include the client's name and a copyright.
Establish a horizontal baseline upon which the front and side views
will rest. If you know what the dimensions of your piece will be, you
can position the baseline to vertically center the drawing on the paper.
Otherwise, just draw the baseline about 2" from the bottom border.
Lay out the rough positions of the three views using light "blocking"
lines. Begin with the front view, referring to your concept sketch or
photo. If you haven't finalized dimensions yet, you can experiment a bit
with the drawing until the proportions look good. Once you're satisfied,
darken the lines to create true "working" lines.
Extend the outer edges of the front view straight up to establish the
width of the top view. Similarly, extend the top and bottom edges of the
front view horizontally to define the height of the side view. Darken
all lines once the basic outlines of each view are determined.
Parts that are hidden by others can be indicated with a dashed line.
Provide a dimension and part symbol (A, B, C, ...) for each
component. This information will be used to construct a bill of
materials.
Provide joinery and construction details only if the piece is fairly
complex and a full-scale drawing will not be created.
Another Drawing Example
Todd Peterson of CutList Plus fame has put together a really nice
online
tutorial for building a writing table. In addition to detailed
construction notes, this tutorial has a complete collection of shop
drawings - the standard orthographic views as well as detailed views of
the legs, drawers, and rails.
To CAD or not to CAD? If you've never created a working drawing
before, I suggest trying it by hand so you can go one-on-one with the
drafting process without getting all caught up in the intricacies of a
computer program. Once you feel comfortable with the process and the
underlying concepts, then go ahead and try a CAD package. Just realize
that unless you're creating a complex item or you build a lot of
furniture, it may be hard to justify the time and effort involved in
learning how to use the software.
I used TurboCAD to create the orthographic drawing of the trestle
table shown above. In the time that it took me to complete the drawing
(and master the learning curve), I could have cranked out a half-dozen
drawings of the table by hand. I also found it time-consuming and
somewhat painful to create curved features compared to using a French
curve. On the other hand, it was a joy to lay out parallel lines, to
copy and paste intricate parts, to undo edits, to zoom in and out, to
lay out dimension lines, ..., all the things that CAD excels at. By the
project's end, I probably could have churned out the drawing in half the
time that a hand drawing would have required. The moral: CAD only makes
sense if you intend to use the package more than once and often enough
to maintain your proficiency in using it.
Full-scale Drawing (Optional)
Some woodworkers like to create full-scale orthographic drawings in
addition to the reduced scale ones. There are several reasons to
consider making a full-scale drawing: the proportions and details can be
reconsidered, direct measurements for components can be easily
retrieved, and templates for curved and irregular parts are ready-made.
On the other hand, full-scale drawings are not practical if the object
to be built is rather simple or if it is quite large.
Full-scale drawings can be drawn in the same manner as reduced-scale
drawings but they often include more detail - wood grain orientation,
joinery, edge profiles, screw hole locations, etc. Hidden structures can
be penciled in with dashed lines or with a different color. Separate
detail drawings and cross sections are another way to show hidden parts.
Perspective Drawing (Optional)
A perspective drawing is similar to a photograph: as the lines of an
object recede toward the back, they appear to converge or become closer
together. The advantage of a perspective drawing over scale and
full-size drawings is that the object looks more like what our eyes
perceive if we viewed the actual object. That is, a three-dimensional
perspective is provided.
Perspective drawings can be time-consuming to make and are not
essential for building a furniture piece if the other drawings are done
well. They do have their place in the commercial world however, and they
can be fun to make. An overview of perspective drawing can be found in
most text books on mechanical drawing.
Bill of Materials and Cut List -> |